Well to be honest, they're not. Not that these aren't awesome genres with some fantastic writers, but there are many more writers who write whatever is selling (often the ones who think writing a book is a fun little side project, like redecorating the guest bedroom.) And sure, we all have bills to pay, I just wish there was a little more diversity. You know?
It just irks me. Maybe it's because I'm writing one of the least popular genres in the history of the world. . . so unpopular it was just recently given a name: New Adult. (And not even having a name helped.) Oh well, I've always been the dork in the corner who refuses to play with the cool kids.
So maybe I'll finish my manuscript and no one will touch it because there isn't much of a market for it, oh well. I'll throw it in a shoe box and bide my time. But I really think there's hope for weirdos like me, partly because of one of my favorite writing quotes:
"If there's a book you really want to read, but it hasn't been written yet, then you must write it."I think most people like that one, but how many people are really following that advice? I am, but I'm known for doing irrational things. The problem is stagnation. I recently looked over a bunch of queries (I won't name the site) and just about every single one was paranormal or fantasy and YA or MG. One of them was so close to Twilight that I was tempted to ask if it was a joke. I didn't, but man I wanted to.
If that's where your muse takes you, by all means go there. But everyone's muses at the same time? Really? Bull, Muses are not influenced by the bottom line. If they were, we'd all be loaded. There's just a major push (from publishers, agents, and ourselves) to write what people are reading. Unfortunately it can push us away from the other, less popular, ideas we have. Or even make us try to force a story that we wouldn't necessarily write under normal circumstances.
But think about this, the market can't fall in love with what isn't there, so write something new! Vampires didn't used to be the new black, remember those days? Yeah, I know, it's been a while.
The way I see it, it's like going to a party, there's always a few groups of people crowded around someone with a great story. So you can stand on your toes and try to join the conversation by the pretzels. Or you can put on a short dress with a loud print and start dancing on the table. Some people will think your nuts, but they're not conversation starters, now are they?
I'd love to see a balance in the market (Bahahaha, are you serious Erica? Never gonna happen!) Yeah, I know. And of course, I want more people to write NA. I'm not going to pretend like that's not part of my reasoning, it is. I'm lonely! Sometimes I feel like the only kid in class who isn't wearing SillyBandz!
I know this is an odd opinion to share when many people reading it are obviously writers of these genres. It may rub some people the wrong way or even down right piss them off, which I can understand. But it's okay, I have a habit of putting my foot in my mouth, and by now I'm used to the taste.
So you tell me, what are you saying in your most recent work(s)? How is what you're saying different? And what would you like to see more of on the best seller lists?

My book is a Fantasy/romance/action with a hint of urban. Its kick-arse and I love it ;p and that's all that matters!
ReplyDeletewww.damselinadirtydress.com
One thing I have learned with this writing to get published lark is that you need alot of patience and a thick skin. While other people do a day's work and get paid, we can spend days writing without any financial rewards and often without validation or understanding from others. We must be mad. LOL!
ReplyDeleteIf I had to sum up the theme of the book I'm working on now, it would be "To thine own self be true." It's not groundbreaking, but it's honest, and I think it's relatable. Your goldfish (greenfish? bluefish?) are mesmerizing. Holy cow, I think I just fed them. Must. Tear. Eyes. Away.
ReplyDeleteI feel your annoyance, Erica. The WIP i am currently working on is a YA/Mainstream/Adult and i have another one in the works which is an Adult/Fantasy/Mainstream/Paranormal.
ReplyDeleteSo, it can be really depressing when a writer is confined rather than writing what other niches of people would enjoy. Isn't that supposed to be the joys of writing?
P.S. Can you explain what this New Adult is all about? Thanks.
@ Rachel: New Adult is college-aged characters, so 20+. Despite the film industry's love affair with college, it's not a very common age group to write about. I'm a senior in college, so I felt compelled to write a character close to my age.
ReplyDelete@Elizabeth: I know, those fish are addictive lol
Erica, I agree there are people out there who just write whatever seems to be popular at the moment. But I don't necessarily think always the case. I know my muse is influenced by what I see, hear, read in everyday life. It stands to reason if there are really good paranormal books out there, other people would think about all the different ways they could craft a story using a vampire/werewolf/alien etc.
ReplyDeletePersonally, when I started my paranormal romance story I never even dreamed it would get finished, much less published. I wrote it because it was what I wanted to write and when I finished, I wanted to share it because I thought it was good. I was just lucky enough that my publisher liked it as much as I did. I wasn't thinking about the market or what was trendy. I just wrote a story I wanted to read.
I can totally understand your frustration and I see where you're coming from, but I don't think everyone is playing a 'follow the leader' game so much as inspired by a genre they enjoy. Trends are bound to happen, just keep in mind they always swing back. Maybe the next trendy thing will be new adult, you never know. :)
I totally get what you're saying. I'm lucky in that my WIP falls into the fantasy MG category - but I've been working on world building since before that was the cool category. And strictly speaking, mine is slightly outside since it's not faeries/vampires/angels/werewolves/etc... but it's my story and its elves of my creation and a world that is all mine with some really cool backstory about where the elves came from and... well, it may never get published. It may not be good enough. It may not be the 'right' kind of fantasy... but then again there's a start to every genre push. Maybe mine's it... and maybe yours is too. When it's a novel you're writing... go with what you love. Because you live with it for a long while.
ReplyDelete@Debbie: Exactly! It really is a huge undertaking, which is why I can't understand how/why some people write a story that isn't "them". If the genre of the moment happens to be the one you love to write, that's really lucky... but obviously not everyone loved writing these genres before they became popular. That's what bums me out.
ReplyDeleteMy genre, mg historical novels-in-verse, is doubly quiet. Still, I was able to sell a book. Believe in what you are creating. Know that you bring something unique to the table.
ReplyDelete@ Caroline: Thank you for the encouragement : ) what is a novel-in-verse?? I'm curious
ReplyDeleteA verse novel is a story told though spare, unrhymed poetry.
ReplyDelete@Caroline: wow, that sounds really difficult! So you ever post excerpts of your work? I'd love to read it : )
ReplyDeleteI don't, but I could recommend some titles:
ReplyDeleteOUT OF THE DUST by Karen Hesse (mg)
LOVE THAT DOG by Sharon Creech (mg)
MY OWN, SYLVIA (the life of Sylvia Plath) by Stephanie Hemphill (ya)